Alright, look. I’ve been staring at spreadsheets and transaction histories for what feels like a decade. Crypto does that to you. One minute you’re chasing the next moonshot, the next you’re drowning in a sea of \”where the hell did that 0.003 ETH come from?\” That’s why I finally caved and tried CoinTracking. Not because I wanted to, mind you. Because TurboTax started giving me that judgmental red error message during import, and my own manual tracking… well, let’s just say it resembled abstract art more than accounting. So, here’s the raw, slightly jaded, experience after wrestling with both their Free and Pro tiers. No sugarcoating, no \”rah-rah crypto\” nonsense. Just what it actually did, and didn’t do, for me.

First off, the free version. It’s… fine? I guess? For someone dabbling with maybe Coinbase and a handful of trades a year? Maybe. Signing up was painless enough, which is a miracle in crypto-land. You get the basics: manual entry (hello, 2017 vibes), CSV imports (godawful for anything beyond simple spot trades), and support for a decent number of exchanges and wallets. Imported my Kraken history. Okay, cool. Saw my buys, sells. Basic profit/loss. Felt a flicker of hope. Then I tried adding my staking rewards from Binance. Nope. Free version doesn’t auto-classify staking income. Or mining income. Or airdrops. Or anything remotely complex. It just dumps it into the transaction list as a generic \”Income.\” Meaning I had to manually go through hundreds of tiny transactions, labeling each one. Remember that feeling of existential dread when facing a mountain of laundry? Yeah. Like that, but with numbers that could summon the IRS.

And APIs? Forget about it on the free plan. You get… 100 transactions? Or 200? Something laughably small. My Binance history alone blew past that limit before breakfast. So, you’re stuck with CSV hell. Ever tried importing a CSV from a DeFi protocol? It’s like trying to assemble IKEA furniture blindfolded. The column headers never match, the timestamps are in some obscure format, and half the transactions look like alien hieroglyphs. Spent a solid Saturday afternoon just trying to get my Uniswap LP positions vaguely recognizable. Ended up with duplicate entries, missing fees, and a profound sense of regret. The free version feels like being given a shovel to dig a swimming pool. Technically possible? Sure. But you’re gonna break your back, and the result will be… questionable.

Then there’s the tax report preview. The free version dangles this carrot. \”Oh, look, you can see what your tax report might look like!\” Emphasis on \”might.\” Because without classifying all those complex transactions properly – which the free version barely helps with – that preview is pure fantasy. It showed me owing significantly less than I instinctively knew was right. Alarm bells. Big ones. That’s the dangerous part. It gives you just enough data to feel informed, but without the tools to make that data accurate. It’s like looking at your bank balance through a foggy window. You get the gist, but the details could ruin you.

So, begrudgingly, I upgraded to Pro. My wallet wept a little. It’s not cheap. Let’s get that out there. But desperation breeds expensive choices. The immediate, visceral difference? API imports. Oh, sweet automation. Connecting my main exchanges (Coinbase Pro, Kraken, Binance) was mostly smooth. Seeing transactions flood in automatically, categorized (mostly!) correctly? That first import felt like watching a magic trick. Staking rewards actually labeled as \”Staking\”? Mining income as \”Mining\”? Small victories, but after CSV purgatory, it felt revolutionary. It handled the sheer volume – thousands of trades, no sweat. That alone saved me literal days of data entry hell. Days I could spend… well, probably just staring at charts feeling anxious, but still. My time.

But Pro isn’t magic. It just gives you better tools to fight the chaos. The classification system is where it starts to earn its keep. Instead of just \”Income,\” you get specific tags: Airdrop, Fork, Mining Reward, Staking, Interest, Payment, even Gift (hopefully you documented that!). This is crucial. Not just for accuracy, but for your sanity when reviewing. Seeing \”Staking Reward – Binance – 0.05 BNB\” is infinitely better than \”Income – 0.05 BNB.\” It builds context. And context is everything when you’re trying to remember if that random influx was a legit airdrop or you just forgot you traded something months ago. It still requires manual review, absolutely. I found plenty it misclassified, especially with complex DeFi stuff – liquidity pool entries/exits are still a nightmare, and bridging transactions often get tangled. But having a fighting chance? Priceless. Well, not priceless. Expensive. But less expensive than an accountant fixing my mess.

The tax reports themselves under Pro… this is where the rubber meets the road, and honestly, where the anxiety peaked. Generating the full FIFO report for the US was straightforward. The interface is dense, but functional. Seeing the final capital gains number pop up was… sobering. In a cold sweat kind of way. But crucially, the detailed transaction report it spits out alongside the summary? That became my bible. It lists every single disposal, showing cost basis, proceeds, gain/loss, and the specific acquisition it matched against (FIFO, LIFO, whatever you chose). This level of granularity is non-negotiable. It’s your audit trail. Being able to drill down into why a specific gain was calculated the way it was saved me hours of forensic accounting on my own. Found a few mismatches where it used an incorrect acquisition date (usually due to a slightly wonky import timestamp), but I could manually adjust the pairing right there. That control is vital. The free version doesn\’t give you this depth, this transparency. It just gives you a number and says \”good luck explaining this.\”

Performance-wise? Pro handled my ~10,000 transactions across 5 years without choking. Searches were fast. Filters worked well (finding all transactions involving a specific obscure altcoin? Done). The mobile app is… usable? Better than nothing for a quick check, but I wouldn’t want to do serious work on it. The desktop browser interface is where you live. It’s not flashy. It’s utilitarian. Feels a bit like an early 2010s enterprise app, but it works. And honestly, after wrestling with this stuff, I’ll take functional over pretty any day. The constant nag to upgrade within the free tier was annoying, but gone in Pro. Small mercies.

Is it perfect? Hell no. The DeFi support, while improving, still feels like it’s playing catch-up. Manually adding complex LP transactions or yield farming strategies involving multiple steps and tokens is still painful. Their auto-sync for DeFi wallets? Spotty at best. I ended up manually importing CSV dumps from Zapper for some positions, and even then, the classification was often wrong, requiring significant manual correction. The cost basis methods are solid for standard trades, but get fuzzy with things like staking rewards – when exactly does that cost basis start? Their documentation is extensive but sometimes feels like navigating a labyrinth. Finding the specific setting for that one obscure thing can be a chore. And yeah, the price. Paying hundreds of dollars a year hurts, especially in a bear market when your portfolio looks like it got hit by a truck. It feels like a tax on being disorganized… which, admittedly, I was. But still. Ouch.

So, where does that leave me? Grudgingly impressed with Pro, honestly. The free version? It’s a demo. A tantalizing, frustrating glimpse of what could be, utterly inadequate for anyone beyond the absolute beginner or someone with a single exchange and a dozen trades. If your crypto life involves more than two exchanges, any DeFi, staking, or more than, say, 50 trades a year? Free will waste your time and potentially get you into hot water with inaccurate reporting. Pro is the necessary evil. It doesn’t make crypto taxes easy. Nothing does. The space is inherently messy. But it makes it manageable. It gives you the tools, the visibility, and the detailed reporting you need to have a prayer of being accurate. It reduced my tax-prep-induced panic from DEFCON 1 to maybe DEFCON 3. That’s… progress? I guess? I’m still not happy about paying for it. It feels like paying a toll for a road that’s constantly under construction and full of potholes. But right now, it’s the only semi-reliable vehicle I’ve found to navigate this mess. So yeah, I renewed. With a sigh, and a hope that maybe next year, things will be simpler. (Spoiler: They won\’t be.)

FAQ